Beta-reader for children's fantasy
Hello!
I am looking for a beta reader to help improve the book. I need a critical outsider's perspective that will point out all the weaknesses.
Genre: children's epic fantasy, with an ecological theme, and a touch of romance.
Audience: middle grade, girls, 8–12 years old.
Length: not finished yet, approximately 40,000 words, will need to be proofread in parts
I need general feedback and proofreading:
Is it interesting to read at all
Plot holes and incomplete motivations.
Continuity errors and inconsistencies.
Inaccuracies or clichés in worldbuilding, conflicts, twists.
Illogical and unrealistic character reactions.
Unfinished or overloaded scenes (pacing, balance of dialogue and description).
Markers of potentially sensitive content (age limits, ethical nuances).
What to remove / deepen / rearrange.
Suggestions for increasing pace and tension.
Advice on uniqueness and "hooks" for publishers.
About the book
A girl named Mila accidentally falls into an underwater world and searches for a way back home. During her search, she enters a city and meets its prince - Iris, who is a mermaid, and a fish named Flinn. In the city, everyone is preparing for the Transparent Dragon Dance, which was once a celebration, but now is a dangerous threat. Together with Iris and Flinn, Mila embarks on a journey full of mysteries, ancient legends, and dangers. Their path leads through water storms, abandoned cities, all the way to the heart of the ocean. All this to help the ocean and to restore the Transparent Dragon Festival, and finally find a way home.
Client's review of cooperation with Tetiana O.
Beta-reader for children's fantasyThank you very much for the work! Tetyana thoroughly analyzed my book, pointed out the strengths and weaknesses, and suggested how to improve the story.
Freelancer's review of cooperation with Anna Luk'yanchuk
Beta-reader for children's fantasyTask setting, communication, payment, involvement in work — everything at the highest level. Thank you and sincerely recommend for cooperation.
-
Having read the synopsis of your book, I already want to read the whole thing to find out how it all ended. We will be reading this book with my son (8 years old), he enjoys books in a similar genre.
I am a philologist and editor, ready to proofread the book and provide suggestions for improving your book on all the points you listed in this task.
Also, as a bonus, you will receive feedback from my young reader 😉
-
421 3 0 Good day, Anna. I can offer my proofreading services for the book. I am a literary editor by profession, working in this field for over 20 years, so I can evaluate and improve any text. I have experience creating a fairy tale book using AI and editing it, preparing it for printing. Cost - 50 UAH per 1000 characters.
-
4365 12 0 Hello.
In my opinion, for completing this task you do not need a beta-reader, but a literary editor.
I can perform the editing for you, also help improve the appeal for publishers, synopsis, annotation, cover letter, list of publisher emails searching for manuscripts in your genre.
If needed, I can assist with turnkey publishing.
The price indicated is an approximate for editing a manuscript of about 300,000 characters with spaces.
Briefly about myself.
… I am one of those who chose education and their profession out of love. I have 14 years of experience in publishing, editing, design, and typesetting of books. With my participation, over 300 publications have been issued. Most of them were done "turnkey" — from manuscript to print run.
With me, your book will not just be published, but will also turn out exactly as you dreamed.
I invite you to visit my website: https://kulinsky.antipublishing.com.ua
and my short portfolio: Freelancehunt
It may also be useful to visit my publishing platform's website: https://antipublishing.com.ua
Thank you,
wishing you light,
Ivan.
-
173 Hello!
I am a practicing psychologist with experience in the field of child development, well aware of the age-specific perception of text and topics for the 8–12 age audience. I have experience editing and analytical reading of texts — in particular focusing on plot logic, character depth, pacing, dialogues, and suitability for the age category.
I would be happy to serve as your beta-reader. I can provide detailed feedback on each of the mentioned points — from overall impression to specific advice on world-building, motivation logic, and emotional response of the characters. I am especially attentive to ethical nuances and potentially sensitive content for this age group.
I am ready to work in parts, at a pace comfortable for you.
I would be glad to contribute to creating an interesting and strong text!
-
3226 113 1 1 Hello! I want to start working on your project today, I am currently available. I am also looking for long-term cooperation. I have a degree in journalism in the publishing and editing program. Excellent knowledge of the Ukrainian language, with 4 years of experience in writing materials, I have written poems and prose works "in the drawer".
My main specialization is SEO articles for blog sites, but I am very interested in writing fiction. The cost of editing is 70 UAH per 1,000 characters with spaces.
Here is a link to my portfolio, where you can verify my literacy, professionalism, and sufficient experience:Google Drive
The order is interesting, so I hope for fruitful cooperation)
-
123 Hello! I am interested in your project — I really love children's fantasy, especially with deeper themes like ecology or emotional growth. I am a journalist and educator by training, a mother of four children, so I have a sense of the age-specific nuances of the text and the dynamics that can engage a young reader.
I am ready to carefully read your text in parts and provide detailed feedback on:
— plot logic and character motivations,
— the coherence of the world-building,
— the balance of descriptions and dialogues,
— the dynamics and tension,
— sensitive content and age appropriateness.
… I can work in the format of comments in Word or Google Docs. If needed — I will prepare an example evaluation of a passage.
I would be happy to become your beta-reader!
-
162 Good day, Ms. Anna!
I will help improve your book. I am a literary editor and can also perform structural editing of a fiction work. I will read your fantasy, considering various aspects, paying special attention to the nuances that interest you. I will provide appropriate suggestions. I have worked as a teacher and editor of textbooks for the New Ukrainian School, so I am familiar with the characteristics of children aged 8–12 years. The deadline and cost of the work depend on the volume of the text. I look forward to working with you.
-
170 I will gladly take on your work, I will read your book with interest and make appropriate comments, especially since I write poetry myself
-
1004 13 0 Hello, Ann! I have extensive experience working with children's fiction as an editor, author, and reader. I help writers turn ideas into a compelling text that is hard to put down. I am attracted to the theme of children's and teenage fantasy in an underwater setting, especially for girls, so I will gladly support you in writing this book. I offer not only proofreading and recommendations but also, if needed, an online writing session, in-depth research of the topic, and editing. Considering that the book is still in the process of being written, I specify a tentative deadline. Please send me a fragment of the text in a private message for review.
-
805 25 0 Hello, Anna. Let's make the Dance of Transparent Dragons a celebration together. I am not a prince, and not a mermaid, but I write well, and I will figure out all the other issues with the text you mentioned without any problem.
-
496 Good day!
I have higher education in journalism and experience in proofreading texts. I previously worked as a beta-reader on the Fixbook website, so I am well-versed in detailed text review and can complete your task in the shortest possible time. I take each task responsibly, and my attention to detail will help ensure high accuracy when making edits. Ready to work quickly and efficiently!
-
1617 153 0 Good day! I would be happy to cooperate. By the way, I have been in Donetsk for 10 years, with which we gladly send your book and will be able to evaluate it from the perspective of a real reader.
Ready to cooperate!
-
202 Hello! I am ready to take on this work, as I have experience in writing literary works myself. I speak proficient Ukrainian and have a good sense of text. I will gladly help improve readability, point out all the advantages, disadvantages, and shortcomings.
The deadline and price depend on the volume.
I look forward to fruitful cooperation!
-
601 7 1 Children's writer, editor, psychologist. I specialize in children's literature. I can proofread your book, following your requirements and requests, and provide constructive comments and advice. Feel free to contact me.
-
1000 32 0 Good day, Anna. I am a writer, the last children's book for the Spanish-speaking market is sold on Amazon. I am very meticulous and critical, but only with the aim of improvement. So write to me. The price is approximate and the deadlines as well. Write, and we will agree.
Best regards, Yulia!
-
1316 13 0 👋 Hello!
📖 I have many years of experience in the publishing field and will gladly perform beta proofreading of the book.
📚 Example of work:
👉Google Drive
🤝 Feel free to contact me, I will be happy to collaborate!
-
2211 141 0 Hello, Anna! I have experience working with children's books. As an editor, I am ready to point out all the flaws if there are any. Feel free to contact me, and we will discuss the details.
-
1070 14 0 1 There is professional beta-reading experience among our authors who have published books. I will send the portfolio in private messages. I can also advise regarding publishers to apply to, or how to publish in collaboration with a literary agent.
-
876 7 0 Hello, Ms. Anna!
I am truly interested in your project, and I am ready to collaborate.
I have six years of experience working with children, especially teenagers. I work as a Ukrainian language and literature teacher, I love reading, so I will gladly help improve your book. Editing and writing fiction are an important part of my professional life.
👉 I can complete a small test task. Contact me, we will discuss the price and deadline in private messages. I look forward to your feedback!
-
412 2 0 I can take on the task. I work as an editor, do proofreading of monograph texts, have philological and historical education. I will gladly re-read the work and, if necessary, perform correction or review. I have a young reader of this age who will appreciate the work according to the age category)
-
193 Hello. Ready to work. Six years of experience working with children, pedagogical education, and boundless love for reading. Interested in your project.
-
705 25 1 Hello, Anna!
I offer my services. I have a philological education, I feel and appreciate the beauty of words, and I also have experience in writing and editing children's fairy tales and stories. I will show samples in private messages.
The time to complete and the cost of the project will depend on the scope of work. We can start cooperation with a small test task.
Contact me – we will communicate.
-
259 Good day! I am happy to take on this work. I love reading books (especially fantasy), so I can quickly read the book and give you a response to your requests. I am fluent in Ukrainian, well-versed in the world of fantasy and romance.
-
2944 222 0 Hello, Anna.
I offer my services, I will gladly read the book and give comprehensive answers to all questions. I love fantasy. Professionally, I am a Ukrainian language teacher, working with teenage children. Feel free to contact me for discussion if my rate interests you.
A similar completed project:
https://freelancehunt.com/project/beta-rider-dlya-hudozhnoyi-knigi/1404203.html
-
652 8 1 Hello, I worked as an editor for a publication, so I think my experience may be useful to you!
-
578 5 0 Hello! I offer you my services. I am fluent in Ukrainian, have experience working with texts of various topics and styles. Write to me, we will discuss the details.
Also, the mother of a teenage girl)