Everything was done quickly and efficiently. I am satisfied with the result. I can't comment on the outcome of the case itself, as I need to wait for all actions and decisions to be made physically, but from the consultation received and the prepared letter, everything is clear to me. Thank you for your work! I recommend.
9
0
Budget: 1200 UAH Deadline: 1 day
Hello! I have familiarized myself with your situation. The dispute seems promising for a detailed legal and technical analysis, as there may be issues regarding the legality of the HOA's refusal to approve the metering unit, as well as the correctness of applying the Methodology for distributing thermal energy.
I have 10 years of legal practice, including experience in the field of housing and communal disputes, HOAs, contractual relations, and protecting property owners' rights. In similar cases, it is important not only to know the legislation but also to understand the technical aspects of heating supply systems and the billing mechanisms.
What I propose:
• a detailed analysis of documents and billing;
• verification of the legality of the HOA's actions;
• analysis of the prospects for installing a metering unit or changing the distribution order;
• preparation of a legal position and a step-by-step action plan;
• if necessary — preparation of official appeals, demands, or further support of the dispute.
Before recommending court or other actions, I always assess the real prospects of the case and the risks for the client.
I would be happy to help you understand the situation and find a practical solution.
Budget: 1500 UAH Deadline: 1 day
Good day, Ms. Irina,
I am ready to assist you in resolving the disputed situation: to analyze the documents and provide recommendations on available ways to protect your rights.
I would be happy to receive your proposal for cooperation.
11
2
Budget: 1500 UAH Deadline: 1 day
Hello! At the time, the homeowners' association did not allow the installation of heat meters in an apartment divided into 4 separate apartments. Legally, the apartment is divided into 4, but the utilities are not. They also did not allow the installation of a heat meter for one unit. We have been paying for heating based on bills that divided the heat losses among all who do not have a meter.
Now the payments have become unaffordable, ranging from 4500 to 5800 UAH per month for 27 sq.m. This means for 4 apartments with a total area of 100 sq.m, it can reach up to 25000 UAH.
When contacting the head of the homeowners' association, we receive the response - return the distribution of apartments back, meaning there is no way to resolve this.
I want to consult and start taking action to change the situation. The best solution is to change nothing in the networks and try to prove that the payment distribution for heating in apartments without meters should be done in a fairer way.
I need an initial analysis of detailed documents to understand what to do next.
Ludwig N.
Winning proposal
7
0
Budget: 2000 UAH Deadline: 10 days
Hello! I am ready to take you on. I will say right away: the requirement of the head of the HOA to "return everything back" is legally untenable. If the objects have already been divided in the Register of Property Rights, they are independent units. The amounts of 4500-5800 UAH for 27 sq.m are obviously anomalous. There is either a gross violation of the relevant Methodology No. 315 of the Ministry of Regional Development in the distribution of the heat losses of the building, or abuse by the management of the HOA, which is "charging" your premises with the over-expenditures of the entire building.
31
0
Budget: 1500 UAH Deadline: 2 days
Hello! Yes, the situation is generally understood, but for the initial analysis, we need to clarify a few points and review the documents.
Please let me know:
1. Is the apartment legally divided into 4 separate apartments officially? Are there extracts from the State Register of Real Property / technical passports / division decisions?
2. Does each of the 4 apartments have a separate address, personal account, and utility service contract, or are the bills handled differently?
3. Who exactly charges for heating: the homeowners' association (HOA), the heating supply organization, or the management company?
4. Is there a written refusal from the HOA regarding the installation of a heat meter? If so, please send it.
5. Have you officially contacted the HOA / heating supplier in writing regarding the installation of a meter or changes to the billing procedure?
6. What type of heating system is in the building: vertical or horizontal distribution?
7. Is there a building heat meter?
8. How many apartments in the building have individual heat meters, and how many do not?
9. How are the charges specified in the bills: for heating the apartment, maintenance fees, losses, distribution of thermal energy, etc.?
10. Have there been decisions made at the general meetings of the HOA regarding the distribution of heat / installation of meters / prohibition of interference in the networks?
11. Have the internal networks changed after the apartment was divided into 4 parts?
12. Are there inspection reports, project documentation, or conclusions from specialists regarding the possibility of installing a metering unit?
For analysis, it would be desirable to send: the latest heating bills for all 4 apartments, the HOA charter, meeting protocols regarding heating/meters, written refusals or correspondence with the HOA chair, documents about the division of the apartment, technical passport/floor plan, and, if available, contracts with the heating supplier.
After reviewing the documents, it will be possible to assess whether there are legal grounds to demand a fairer billing procedure, challenge the actions of the HOA, or initiate official resolution of the issue through meetings, the supplier, or other authorities.
Proposals concealed
The list does not show proposals concealed by the client or freelancer with a Plus profile, as well as proposals violating rules
